Skip to main content ITU
Logo
  • Programmes
    • BSc Programmes
    • BSc in Global Business Informatics
    • BSc in Digital Design and Interactive Technologies
    • BSc in Software Development
    • BSc in Data Science
    • Applying for a BSc Programme
    • MSc Programmes
    • MSc in Digital Innovation & Management
    • MSc in Digital Design and Interactive Technologies
    • MSc in Software Design
    • MSc in Computer Science
    • MSc in Data Science
    • MSc in Games
    • Applying for an MSc Programme
    • Student Life
    • Women in tech
    • Student Organisations at ITU
    • Labs for students
    • Practical Information for International Students
    • Study Start
    • Study and Career Guidance
    • Guest Students
    • Who can be a Guest Student
    • ITU Summer University
    • Exchange Student
    • Become an exchange student at ITU
    • Open House
    • Open House - MSc Programmes
    • Open House - BSc programmes
  • Professional Education
    • Master in IT
    • Master in IT Management
    • Single Subjects
    • About single subjects
    • Contact
    • Contact us here
  • Research
    • Departments
    • Business IT Department
    • Computer Science Department
    • Digital Design Department
    • Research Groups and Labs
    • Research Groups
    • Labs
    • Research Centres
    • Centre for Computer Games Research
    • Center for Computing Education Research
    • Centre for Digital Welfare
    • Centre for Information Security and Trust
    • European Blockchain Centre
    • Research Centre for Government IT
    • Research Institutes
    • Danish Institute for IT Program Management
    • Selected Research Themes
    • Artificial intelligence
    • Big Data
    • Climate IT
    • Computer games
    • Blockchain
    • Digitalization
    • IT security
    • Find a Researcher
    • Faculty Search
    • PhD Programme
    • About the PhD Programme
    • Available PhD Positions
    • PhD Courses
    • Research Ethics and Integrity
    • Good Scientific Practice
    • PhD Defences
    • Technical Reports
    • Technical Reports
  • Collaboration
    • Collaboration with students
    • Project collaboration
    • Project Market
    • Student worker
    • Project postings
    • Job and Project bank
    • Portraits of ITU graduates
    • Employer Branding
    • IT Match Making
    • Hiring an ITU student or graduate
    • Make a post in the job bank
    • Research collaboration
    • Licensing Opportunities
    • Open Entrepreneurship
    • Research collaboration
    • Industrial PhD
    • Hire an Industrial PhD
    • Innovation and entrepreneurship
    • ITU Business Development
    • ITU Startup programme
    • Startup stories
  • About ITU
    • Vacancies
    • Press
    • ITU Alumni
    • News
    • Calendar
    • Contact
    • About ITU
  • DK
We judge the success of digital transformation projects in wrong ways
ITU  /  Press  /  News from ITU  /  We judge the success of digital transformation projects in wrong ways

We judge the success of digital transformation projects in wrong ways

IT projects are almost impossible to compare to each other and often judgements of good or right projects are based on unconscious use of fundamental devices. Associate professor at the IT University, Arisa Shollo, advices organizations to become more aware of the kind of the judgement devices they use in project selection processes as they lead to different kind of projects being selected . Projects within digital transformation would rarely be selected based on business cases and cost benefit models.

Arisa SholloProfessional educationBusiness IT Departmentbusinessinnovationmanagement

Written September 20, 2017 9:56 AM by Ninna Gandrup

»

But organizations should start investigating where these judgements come from and what kind of projects and eventually organizations they lead to.

Arisa Shollo, Associate professor at the IT University and teacher at the course IT Project and Portfolio Management

«

- Most organizations make judgements of weather a project is good enough or not based on different devices, such as business cases, personal networks, experts and so on. But organizations should start investigating where these judgements come from and what kind of projects and eventually organizations they lead to, says Arisa Shollo.

The business case as a device does not stand alone
In many organizations a business case is required before you even start a project. But according to Arisa Shollo the business case is used as a one of the devices and does rarely stand alone when judging the selection or the success of a project.

- What does it mean to have a good or the right project? Where does this judgement come from? Is it a matter of strategy, taste or needs? The focus should be on where these judgements come from and which devices are used to shape them. There is no single device you can use to get success, but you need to reflect on the different devices and be conscious about the kind of projects they make room for. Everyone uses devices and all the devices have implications, says Arisa Shollo and explains the most common devices used for judging projects starting with the business case:

»

A business case is a mechanism, which shapes the idea of a financially sound project according to cost-benefit analysis or benefit-cost ratio. And you have to consider, how much you want the selection and evaluation of projects to be based on a unidimensional scale.

Arisa Shollo, Associate professor at the IT University and teacher at the course IT Project and Portfolio Management

«

- A business case is a mechanism, which shapes the idea of a financially sound project according to cost-benefit analysis or benefit-cost ratio. And you have to consider, how much you want the selection and evaluation of projects to be based on a unidimensional scale. What limitations are there to the mindset of business cases e.g. calculating, aggregating, abstracting? What kind of projects does the business case make room for and what projects are excluded?

Arisa Shollo
Arisa Shollo has a Ph.D. and is Asociate Professor at the IT University of Copenhagen. Her main research areas include several objects in the field between Organizational Decision-making, Management of IT and Decision Support. In particular she is interested in analyzing companies' use of information with Organizational Decision-making as the main theoretical approach. Under this belong objects concerning how organizations collect, analyze and use information in reaching organizational decisions. She has published and presented her work at a number of major international journals and conferences, including Journal of Strategic Information Systems, Information Systems Journal, ICIS, ECIS, Academy of Management, EGOS, and NFMOC.

Another device is expert intuition, which is quite the opposite of the business case:

- When expert intuitive judgment is used in evaluating projects room for more creative projects becomes available. Expert intuition cannot be articulated; it is usually expressed in terms of “gut feelings” and thus allows for more playful, experimental and potentially disruptive ideas. At the same time, however, using intuition means that you need to be aware of the biases that might be introduced in the process says Arisa Shollo. Potential success here is not measured based on calculating the return on investment but on a belief and commitment to success.

Besides business cases and intuitive judgments other devices could be: ranking lists, sponsors, experts (e.g. software architects and others with specific domain knowledge), personal networks and professional networks, labels, brands ect. All of these devices shape decision makers’ judgments and become the central mechanisms in the qualification of projects. They are active forces that complement, compete with and shape each other as well as the collective judgement in certain directions.

- An expert might judge the outcome different than personal networks or the business case. And with labels such as “strategic project”, “foundation project” and so on you categorize the project, which also shapes how people think of the project. It is important to be aware of the devices that are used in the organization and the power each of them have in qualifying a project. As well, being conscious when using specialists/experts’ opinion as it might focus on technical aspects and leave other elements in the background, explains Arisa Shollo.

Aligning judgment devices with innovation strategy
Often there will be more than one device in use, which could cause imbalance or conflict to qualifying projects. But more importantly the emergent use of devices is the actual innovative strategy of the company.

- Often you hear that the only thing you need is a sound business case. But often the business case conflicts with the experts’ opinion or the decision maker’s intuition. Organizations have to consider which devices are more important and how these devices work together to qualify a project. The more an organization emphasizes or promotes the use of one device the more imbalance there will be, says Arisa Shollo.

»

The devices needed to support a new business idea or digital transformation initiatives are very different from those supporting the implementation of a new ERP system or upgrades of old systems.

Arisa Shollo, Associate professor at the IT University and teacher at the course IT Project and Portfolio Management

«

Different devices allow the qualification of different kind of projects as any device highlights certain aspects while undermines others. The weight that organizations give to different devices is also a choice of innovation strategy. What kind of projects do you make room for? Do you make room for more efficiency, incremental improvements or experimental ideas?

- The devices needed to support a new business idea or digital transformation initiatives are very different from those supporting the implementation of a new ERP system or upgrades of old systems. The best advice is to consider what it means to use e.g. business case as a device with its focus on cost and benefit. What will happen to the project, if you choose this device? If you go for digital transformation projects, does it make sense to use business case as a device to qualify this kind of projects? And how should project success or failure be measured when value and benefit are so uncertain and ambiguous, explains Arisa Shollo and continues:

- Things with uncertain value are defined by taste, not benefit/cost ratio. It is like talking about the choice between beer and wine. No matter how cheap beer is, it is not the same as wine. At the end of the day, it is a matter of taste. And if what you really want is wine, you cannot settle for beer even though the cost is very appealing. It is the same with digital transformation projects.

Course: IT Project and Portfolio Management

The organization and management of an IT project is of growing importance for many organizations, whether in the private or public sector. Different perspecitves are important for the understanding of the IT project, the challenges and hence the type of management pursued. The overall goal of the course are to enable the student to analyze, reflect on and manage an IT project in an organizational context. The first part of the course introduces the students to the concepts, theories and prescriptions of how managers should practice project management and portfolio management. The second part of the course shows how and why these concepts, theories and prescriptions usually fail in real life. New theoretisation based on what actually happen in practice is introduced and discussed.

Read more about the course here.

News

Rasmus Ejlers Møgelberg and Jonas Fritsch receive grants from IRFD

Rasmus Ejlers Møgelberg and Jonas Fritsch receive grants from IRFD

May 10, 2022

The two researchers – from Computer Science and Digital Design at the IT University respectively – have each secured a grant of approximately 2.8 million kroner for their research projects.

European Blockchain Center announces new partnership

European Blockchain Center announces new partnership

April 28, 2022

The European Blockchain Center at the IT University of Copenhagen is partnering with SupraOracles to explore future collaborative efforts to provide value to the blockchain industry on a global scale.

Can robots help prevent anxiety attacks in children?

Can robots help prevent anxiety attacks in children?

April 26, 2022

Morten Roed Frederiksen from Computer Science at ITU has received 1.6 million kroner from Independent Research Fund Denmark for at research project that aims to make robots better at understanding human emotion. The goal is to create technology that may help children with anxiety.

Professor Sebastian Risi receives grant to develop policy learning with neural networks

Professor Sebastian Risi receives grant to develop policy learning with neural networks

April 20, 2022

Professor in the Digital Design Department at the IT University of Copenhagen, Sebastian Risi, has received a grant of approximately 550,000 Danish kroner for his work on neural cellular automata to grow neural network policies capable of adapting to novel complex reinforcement learning tasks.

New research may help improve Copenhagen’s bicycle infrastructure

New research may help improve Copenhagen’s bicycle infrastructure

March 28, 2022

A newly released research paper shows how network analysis can serve as a cost-efficient support tool for bicycle infrastructure planning. The research has been conducted by analyzing the street network in Copenhagen based on data from OpenStreetMap.

ITU professor takes critical approach to green tech, secures prestigious grant

ITU professor takes critical approach to green tech, secures prestigious grant

March 17, 2022

Professor at the IT University of Copenhagen’s Business IT department Steffen Dalsgaard has won the prestigious ERC Consolidator Grant. The almost two million Euro grant will enable him and his colleagues to critically examine IT and sustainability across the globe.

We need to talk about marine renewable energy

We need to talk about marine renewable energy

March 3, 2022

Denmark lacks neither ocean waves nor pioneering scientists and innovators who are dreaming about harnessing energy from them. Professor at IT University of Copenhagen Brit Ross Winthereik, who headed research into initiatives in wave energy innovation around the Atlantic, explains why we are still waiting to see a booming wave energy industry.

IT University to suspend all cooperation with Russia and Belarus

IT University to suspend all cooperation with Russia and Belarus

March 2, 2022

Along with Denmark’s other universities, ITU will be suspending all bilateral institutional cooperation with the states of Russia and Belarus going forward. Current exchange programme participants will not be affected by the measure.

New blockchain governance standard to generate trust and accountability in the market

New blockchain governance standard to generate trust and accountability in the market

February 28, 2022

The new standard, developed by Professor Roman Beck at the IT-University and Danish Standard, will ensure greater transparency, interoperability, and accountability in the use of blockchain and DLT systems. Professor Roman Beck has recently received AIS’s Impact Award for his work in the field.

Using Minecraft to explore climate change topics with school children

Using Minecraft to explore climate change topics with school children

February 8, 2022

Few of the world’s most popular games deal directly with climate issues. However, games can still be used to make gamers think about real world problems, says Associate Professor, Hans-Joachim Backe, who is developing tools for teachers to discuss climate issues based on for example Minecraft.

Digitizing the Amazon: How to use the rainforest without ruining it

Digitizing the Amazon: How to use the rainforest without ruining it

February 8, 2022

There is a lot of hope that the digital, material, and biological innovations of the Fourth Industrial Revolution will help us save the Amazon rainforest. However, the real impact of the new bio economy is yet to be revealed. Researchers from the IT University will study the outcome of Amazônia 4.0.

How do we secure critical technologies from tampering? The answer may be sending them into orbit

How do we secure critical technologies from tampering? The answer may be sending them into orbit

January 20, 2022

At the IT University of Copenhagen, Associate Professor Bernardo David, is working on a joint research project that aims to send satellites that power cryptographic and blockchain applications into orbit in order to secure them from tampering and to enable time-based primitives based on communication delays.

ITU PhD fellow named Game Changer by gaming industry mainstay

ITU PhD fellow named Game Changer by gaming industry mainstay

January 5, 2022

PhD fellow at the Center for Computer Games Research at the IT University of Copenhagen, Leon Y. Xiao, is new to ITU, but his research into the legal and ethical aspects of the gaming industry has already made an impact. Gaming industry mainstay, GamesIndustry.biz, recently named him one of 2021’s Game Changers.

Martin Tvede Zachariasen steps down as Vice-Chancellor

Martin Tvede Zachariasen steps down as Vice-Chancellor

December 20, 2021

Martin Tvede Zachariasen steps down as Vice-Chancellor of the IT University after three years in office. Martin Tvede Zachariasen’s resignation takes effect December 31, 2021.

European Blockchain Center announces International blockchain school and Nordic Blockchain Summit in early 2022

European Blockchain Center announces International blockchain school and Nordic Blockchain Summit in early 2022

December 8, 2021

The International Blockchain School will be held at IT University of Copenhagen on January 24-28th, 2022. On the final day of classes, the students will present their projects at the public event, Nordic Blockchain Summit.

ITU’s Mogens Jacobsen wins prestigious art grant

ITU’s Mogens Jacobsen wins prestigious art grant

December 8, 2021

The artist Mogens Jacobsen who teaches at Digital Design at the IT University of Copenhagen creates art inspired by technology and scientific research. Today, he is the recipient of a grant from the prestigious Niels Wessel Bagge Art Foundation.

ITU researcher secures prestigious fellowship to empower citizen cooperation

ITU researcher secures prestigious fellowship to empower citizen cooperation

December 7, 2021

Associate Professor of Computer Science at the IT University of Copenhagen, Luca Maria Aiello, has won the Carlsberg Foundation’s prestigious Young Researcher Fellowship for a project that aims to facilitate citizen coordination in the face of global challenges such as climate change.

CDV Podcast: Could your cat be used to store your family photos?

CDV Podcast: Could your cat be used to store your family photos?

December 1, 2021

The incomprehensible amounts of digital data we store is a real climate burden. In the Center for Digital Welfare's podcast, host Anders Kjærulff and Assistant Professor James Maguire, discuss research initiatives on environmentally friendly data storage.

Business travel plays vital role in economic growth, according to ITU researcher

Business travel plays vital role in economic growth, according to ITU researcher

November 24, 2021

As a thought experiment Associate Professor of Computer Science at the IT-University, Michele Coscia, theorized that global GDP would drop significantly if business travel on a global scale ceased – now the global COVID-19 shutdown has proven his theory in practice.

Public debate: Do Big Data and law enforcement go hand in hand?

Public debate: Do Big Data and law enforcement go hand in hand?

November 10, 2021

On December 14, the IT University headed research project CUPP and PROSA are hosting a public seminar and debate on data driven policing. Panelists include Palantir Technologies representative Paula Kift, former DPO of the National Police of Denmark, Christian Wiese Svanberg, and Jesper Lund from the IT Political Association.

Contact us

Phone
+45 7218 5000
E-mail
itu@itu.dk

All contact information

Web Accessibility Statement

Find us

IT University of Copenhagen
Rued Langgaards Vej 7
DK-2300 Copenhagen S
Denmark
How to get here

Follow us

ITU Student /
Privacy /
EAN-nr. 5798000417878/
CVR-nr. 29 05 77 53

This page is printed from https://en.itu.dk/research/portalplaceholder?layoutfraction=top&langRef=https://pure.itu.dk/portal/da/organisations/digital-design(d065e6c2-4fae-4d68-ad04-70aec25d2d5e)/clippings.html?page=29